PR Week in Review 07.22.07

Week in Review StrumpetteI poked Amanda Chapel this week. I was respectful, took proper precaution and I think it was good, if not brief, for both of us. Emboldened by my first successful poke on Facebook I began to poke others. With all this indiscriminate poking going on it’s no wonder that this online community is propagating at an alarming rate.  A “poke” on Facebook is equivalent of saying ‘yo, wassup’ and then moving on until you get some kind of response. You poke, gather friends, join groups, add all kinds of widgets and doohickeys to your profile and something is supposed to happen. Your life changes? You find the perfect mate, the perfect job, zing! make that connection you dreamed of your whole life? Or you simply waste more time futzing around the Net. — See the rest of the story on Strumpette

PR Blog News

↑ Grab this Headline Animator

“Really good PR is so rare”

Those are the words of Jodi Kantor (left) of The New York Times.  She recalls few times when she dealt with a PR person who really made a difference in a story, someone who was able to ‘anticipate’ what the Arts & Leisure section, which she used to edit, might need. It’s a digitial world but it’s an old story. PR people aren’t reading the paper and thinking like journalists. Kantor now covers politics in general, and Barack Obama specifically, for NYT.

Kantor was on a panel called “The Era of Citizen Journalism” with Dan Gillmor, Director of the Center for New Citizen Media, moderated by Steve Rubel, Micropersuasion blogger with Edelman’s me2revolution.  The event, held earlier this week and archived with bios, links, and videos on this web page, were part of the Edelman/PR Week New Media Academic Summit.

[Read more...]

PR Online Convergence Roundup

Feel an empty void and need to fill it? Try public relations. 

Jason CalacanisJason Calacanis, the luncheon speaker here today at PR Online Convergence, says he used to have a voice mail that essentially told PR people to screw off. Now he’s speaking at a PR conference. He’s mellowed over the years since I saw him at the last boom in 1999 but he’s matured less. He likes to have fun, with others and himself. He sold his blog company to AOL for $30 million and he’s still having fun. You want to hate the guy.

But he’s from Brooklyn, he grew up in the same neighborhood I did (Bay Ridge) and I can’t do that. He’s too funny. And he’s serious when he says SEO sucks and it’s about gaming the system and it’s wrong and will disappear. He’s serious when he wonders what Edelman was thinking with its Acer Ferrari blog giveaway or the fake Wal-Marting of America. He’s serious when he speaks of authenticity, being true to your ‘voice’, creating compelling content and kung fu blogging paractices he (or someone like him) sometimes employs (and I thought I was the only one).

[Read more...]

Venality. Gluttony. Greed. Sloth. Vengeance. PR.

beastLos Angeles — Transparency, authenticity, full disclosure – these are buzz terms we hear every day in online PR (especially here at the PR Online Convergence conference).  There is a utopian trust in the “wisdom of the crowd” and the democratization of information and the self-correcting, self-policing Internet. These are nice concepts that go along with reading Siddhartha and marching for world peace. But this is PR. 

In reality, we are flogged by agency bosses and clients to “get results” now.  That usually means by any means necessary. Spam and telemarket the media, beg, bend the truth, call in your chits – you don’t get three ‘hits’ today that client is out the door and you are in the hot seat. In order to be successful at media relations – still synonymous with public relations in most circles – you need to be a beast, not a saint. Where is the disconnect?

[Read more...]

Monday Morning Coming Down

I am pleased to be doing the “Week In Review” column on Strumpette, starting today, with analysis of two of our favorite subjects, Edelman and Wal-Mart. Check it out.Blogger & Podcasting Magazine

We have our own magazine: Go to Blogger & Podcaster now to get your free inaugural, online edition. You can read the magazine in a cool reader online format that makes it fun and replicates the print copy. Robert Scoble, ubiquitous uber blogger, is on the cover, there are “how to” features, reviews on new technology, event previews, and ads that talk to you. Of course there are several podcasts to support the print and online copy. Congratulations to publisher Larry Genkin for jumping out there with a much needed new mag.

Rubel gets serious. A chastened Steve Rubel took a few days off fom his blog last week to do some sans-blog soul searching after a dustup with PC Mag editor Jim Louderback.  A 4/23 post on the The Participation Ladder sparks discssion of how many people in the blogosphere are inactive and spectators, as opposed to joiners and creators.  In response to Rubel’s twitter about office dress etiquette: wear your shirt out on dress-down Friday, Steve. Be a wild man.

Yankee go home. Where are the Yankees going in two years? See New Yankee Stadium Construction for progress on the new Yankee Stadium on the site across the street from the old stadium.  I hope we don’t have to wait two years for the Yankees to show some new life and start winning ball games. 

Podcast expo set. The Podcast & New Media Expo is set for September 28-30 in Ontario, California, for a very reasonable $249 for full access to the entire event.

crayon does Coke. crayon has launched its “Virtual Thirst” competition for Coca-Cola and in the process sparked robust discussion on its social media press release (SMR). More on this later in the week.

Rubel Denies Leaving Edelman For Twitter Rehab

Loose Twitter twaddle may have gotten ”A list” PR blogger Steve Rubel in hot water but he vows to remain at Edelman. 

Rubel had to publicly apologize yesterday to Jim Louderback, Editor in chief of PC magazine, for twitting that he threw PC magazine in the trash. Louderback wondered aloud in a guest column on Strumpette that perhaps his 11 million readers were not important to Edelman clients and maybe PC magazine should boycott all Edelman pitches.

Steve Rubel Twitter headAgghhh. That’s media death to a PR firm that pitches PC magazine for a variety of consumer tech clients. The shiny head Yoda had to Google “Apology 101″ and approximate contrition on his blog, but that does not begin to address the issue here.

Rubel’s posts have recently grown more cautious and dour as the Blog Bubble Bursts and clients are reluctant to throw good money into the PR 2.0 blackhole. Value is now trumping experimentation as the economy constricts and that old monster, fear, shrinks budgets.  

So what is Rubel’s value? He recently posted that he was deleting pitches on his computer and that made him feel like a journalist.  On a recent Twitter he dissed CNet. Media relations is obviously not his strong suit, and he is unaware of how many Edelman clients depend on PC magazine and CNet to reach their audience.

Asked by PRBlogNews if there is any truth to the reports that he is leaving Edelman, Rubel replied: “Zero. What reports? Strumpette? Please.”

The real question: If Rubel has no direct billable accountability, as a tarnished brand, has he become expendable to Edelman?

[Read more...]

Anatomy of a Blogspat

earthWhen you look from space you see flare ups across the earth, weather systems, lightning, fires. The skies are always in motion and the earth is revolving. The same with the blogosphere. Little flare ups across the globe sometimes lead to bigger questions, resolutions, or all out war.  This keyboard I am typing on is merely the hardware, emotion still goes into it and that can make blogspats downright ugly. The Kathy Sierra fiasco (read Strumpette’s excellent dissection) is like the O.J. Simpson of blogspats. As ugly and bizarre and sensationalist as you can get in a virtual world. Then there are the little schoolyard brawls that are constantly brewing – like the one I inadvertently (or intentionally?) kicked off here last week.

Rosen says Mark Rose is a clown

There it is, Jay, that’s the headline you wanted to see here to counter the headline to the post I wrote on your presentation at the New York Social Media Club last week. See post: Jay Rosen - I Can Do Whatever The F%#k I Want

[Read more...]

Edelman Revolution At The Crossroads

“I still find some bloggers unwilling to acknowledge the positive role played by PR people; we are sometimes demonized as floggers or Richard Edelmanworse,” Richard Edelman says in the following interview with PRBlogNews.

Richard Edelman (right) is the CEO of the firm that bears the family name. Richard is the son of Daniel J., the founder and architect of the world’s largest independent public relations firm (by far), with nearly $325 million in net fees last year. In September 2004 Richard launched a blog called 6AM that secured his personal imprint on the firm, signaled a big move into the blogging/PR 2.0 space, and presaged the new era of Pioneer Thinking. From a branding and financial perspective, Pioneer Thinking has been a stellar success. Edelman net fees grew nearly 24% last year, three times the rate of the number two independent, Ruder Finn (according to O’Dwyer’s). Edelman is the hot shop in PR.

That success has come with a great deal of scrutiny, public analysis, and a constant stream of criticism. Richard Edelman’s drive to spread the mantra of the “horizontal conversation” through its many practices and 46 offices worldwide has been hampered by persistent questions about its tactics and operations. Edelman takes a thumpin’ in the April 2 story on Wal-Mart in the New Yorker, the latest in a string of stories that try to pierce the veil that cover Edelman’s strategies and tactics. Considering his constant posts that beg for understanding, it is curious that Richard Edelman is still widely misunderstood.

[Read more...]

Jay Rosen – I Can Do Whatever The F@#k I Want

“I am a tenured professor of journalism, I can do whatever the fuck I want,” said Jay Rosen (right), NYU tenured professor of journalism. Rosen was speaking at the New York Social Media Club meeting, at Edelman Worldwide New York headquarters, last Tuesday.  

Rosen was explaining why mainstream media would never undertake his current project of “Pro-Am” journalism fittingly called  Assignment Zero. The schtick is to combine ”citizen journalists” and “professional” journalists to collaborate on a giant, evolving story.  Rosen says he already has 700 people signed up for the project, nearly triple what they expected. Every edit, thought, revision is recorded on the web. All this is intended to prove … ?

[Read more...]

Rubel Succumbs To Twitter Twaddle As Head Glows Brighter

10:04 AM: I go to the bathroom and realize there is no toilet paper 10:08 AM: I steal toilet paper from Starbuck’s (shhh, don’t tell). 10:12 AM: I am back in bathroom and … do you really want to know what I do? Did you know that Steve Rubel went to bed at 10:02 PM Sunday night? Do you know that a guy in Italy, right now, is jabbing a pen in his ear and picking his nose?

Steve Rubel shiny head Yoda levitates in Twitter

Twitter, in case you are blessed by not having any maniacal Twits around you, is this ultra annoying little widget that informs you of every inane move and miniscule thought of other Twits around the globe. “A list” blogger, shiny head Yoda and incorrigible link whore Steve Rubel (right) is head Twit. He promised days ago on his blog never to mention the “T” word again but that has not stopped him from obsessively twitting.

Somebody stop Rubel before he twits again.

In a recent Advertising Age article Rubel gushed that Twitter “rocked the web” with an “avalanche of buzz” because blogging lumerati Robert Scoble and Jason Calacanis were now Twitting (“I am in a cab on my way to the airport” “I am buying a latte” “I just burped”). Rubel is agog that this “global phenomenon” can be viewed real-time through Twittervision.com and promises more great applications to come. Does Rubel have a stake in the company? Has he gone too far up the river … have his methods become unsound? Are there people at Edelman who actually have to sit through meetings with Rubel while he gushes Twitter twaddle?

[Read more...]